I Shouldn't Be Surprised
from Water for Elephants
Original (2024)
I Shouldn't Be Surprised is a song from Water for Elephants. Sing I Shouldn't Be Surprised alongside real Broadway performers at Sing with the Stars in New York City.
Sing This Song LiveCharacters
Characters who perform this song:
From the show
I Shouldn't Be Surprised appears in Water for Elephants.
View show details →Frequently Asked Questions
- What is I Shouldn't Be Surprised?
- I Shouldn't Be Surprised is a Broadway song from Water for Elephants.
- What show is I Shouldn't Be Surprised from?
- I Shouldn't Be Surprised is from Water for Elephants, a Broadway musical.
- Can I sing I Shouldn't Be Surprised at Sing with the Stars?
- Sing with the Stars features songs from many Broadway shows including I Shouldn't Be Surprised. Members sing karaoke alongside real Broadway performers at live nights in NYC. Request an invite.
Other songs from Act 1
All songs from Water for Elephants
View all 22 songs →Love I Shouldn't Be Surprised?
Sing I Shouldn't Be Surprised alongside real Broadway performers at Sing with the Stars — invite only musical evenings in NYC. Join 2,400+ happy guests and counting.
"The vibe was 10 out of 10" — Cindy from Manhattan
Request Your Invitation →