What is I Shouldn't Be Surprised?

I Shouldn't Be Surprised is a Broadway song from Water for Elephants.

What show is I Shouldn't Be Surprised from?

I Shouldn't Be Surprised is from Water for Elephants, a Broadway show.

Can I request I Shouldn't Be Surprised for a Sing with the Stars performance?

Yes! You can request I Shouldn't Be Surprised for future Sing with the Stars performances in New York City. Use the request form on this page to let us know you'd like to see this song featured in our upcoming setlists.

I Shouldn't Be Surprised

from Water for Elephants

I Shouldn't Be Surprised is a song from Water for Elephants. Request this song for future Sing with the Stars performances in New York City.

Request This Song

From the show

I Shouldn't Be Surprised appears in Water for Elephants.

View show details →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is I Shouldn't Be Surprised?: I Shouldn't Be Surprised is a Broadway song from Water for Elephants.
What show is I Shouldn't Be Surprised from?: I Shouldn't Be Surprised is from Water for Elephants, a Broadway show.
Can I request I Shouldn't Be Surprised for a Sing with the Stars performance?: Yes! You can request I Shouldn't Be Surprised for future Sing with the Stars performances in New York City. Use the request form on this page to let us know you'd like to see this song featured in our upcoming setlists.